College Football Week 10: The Playoff Picture Is About to Get a Whole Lot Clearer
Miami heads to South Bend without its biggest weapon. Ohio State needs a response against Oregon. Alabama walks into Death Valley. And the Holy War might decide who controls the Big 12.
Nobody asked for a quiet Saturday in college football.
Good. Because we're not getting one.
The first College Football Playoff rankings are officially here, and the committee couldn't have asked for a better follow-up. Seven matchups between ranked teams. National championship contenders heading into hostile environments. Conference title races hanging in the balance. And several programs that could go from playoff hopefuls to playoff long shots in about three hours.
No. 1 Miami is undefeated but suddenly missing its most explosive player. Notre Dame is fighting for its postseason life. Ohio State is trying to recover from a loss to USC. Alabama has to survive LSU in Baton Rouge. And two top-10 teams are about to settle the Holy War with a potential first-round playoff bye in the balance.
That's before we even get to Georgia–Ole Miss, Kentucky–Tennessee, or an Iowa team that just embarrassed Wisconsin.
This isn't a weekend where the playoff picture gets a little clearer.
This is a weekend where somebody's entire season falls apart.
Here's how we see Saturday unfolding.
No. 1 Miami at No. 11 Notre Dame: The Hurricanes Don't Need Malachi Toney to Win
Saturday, 7:30 PM ET | South Bend, Indiana
Let's address the elephant in the room.
Miami losing Malachi Toney is a massive deal.
The sophomore receiver has been one of the most electric players in college football, piling up 73 receptions, 1,027 yards, and 13 touchdowns through eight games. Now, a high ankle sprain requiring surgery will keep him out of the biggest game of Miami's season.
You don't replace that production overnight.
But here's where we're going against the growing Notre Dame hype:
Miami is still winning this football game.
The Hurricanes are 8-0 for a reason, and that reason isn't exclusively Malachi Toney.
Quarterback Darian Mensah has been absurdly efficient this season, completing more than 80% of his passes while directing one of the country's most dangerous offenses. Miami's offensive line, running game, and ability to generate explosive plays don't suddenly disappear because one receiver gets hurt.
Yes, Notre Dame has an outstanding secondary. Yes, South Bend at night is one of the toughest environments in college football. And yes, the Irish have plenty of motivation after landing at No. 11 in the initial playoff rankings.
But Notre Dame has its own problems.
Leading tackler Drayk Bowen and starting cornerback DJ McKinney are both unavailable. That's not exactly ideal when you're preparing to defend one of the nation's most efficient quarterbacks.
Miami's bigger concern might actually be on the other side of the ball.
Notre Dame quarterback CJ Carr has thrown 18 touchdowns against just one interception, and the Hurricanes have been vulnerable to explosive passing plays. If Carr gets comfortable, Miami could find itself in a shootout.
Still, we're not ready to abandon the nation's No. 1 team because of one injury.
Miami has too much offensive talent, too much to play for, and a quarterback capable of winning this game without his favorite target.
It won't be pretty. It might come down to the final possession.
But we're taking the Hurricanes.
BANTRYM PREDICTION: MIAMI WINS A CLOSE ONE.
No. 23 Oregon at No. 12 Ohio State: The Buckeyes Have to Respond
Saturday, 3:30 PM ET | Columbus, Ohio
Remember when Ohio State looked like it was cruising toward another playoff appearance?
USC had other plans.
The Buckeyes walked into Los Angeles last weekend and left with a 30-18 loss, their second defeat of the season. Suddenly, a team with national championship expectations is facing a game it really cannot afford to lose.
And the opponent?
Oregon.
The Ducks aren't exactly having the season people envisioned, either. They're 5-3, coming off a 34-26 win over Northwestern, and have been inconsistent away from Eugene.
That makes this one of the most interesting matchups on the entire slate.
Ohio State has the defensive talent to make life miserable for Oregon. The Buckeyes also have home-field advantage and the kind of urgency that tends to bring out a different level of intensity.
The concern is their offense.
Freshman quarterback Luke Fahey is still navigating the growing pains of leading a major program. Oregon will test his decision-making, especially if the Buckeyes fall behind early.
But we think Ohio State's defense is the difference.
Oregon has enough talent to make this competitive, but the Buckeyes should be able to control field position, limit explosive plays, and force the Ducks into uncomfortable situations.
This isn't the same Ohio State team that entered the season with a clear path to the playoff.
But it is still a team capable of beating Oregon at home.
And if the Buckeyes lose again?
The committee is going to have a very uncomfortable conversation.
BANTRYM PREDICTION: OHIO STATE BOUNCES BACK AND BEATS OREGON.
No. 5 Alabama at No. 14 LSU: Death Valley Is About to Get Loud
Saturday, 3:30 PM ET | Baton Rouge, Louisiana
There are few things better in college football than Alabama and LSU playing a meaningful November game.
And this one has serious playoff consequences.
Alabama enters as the higher-ranked team, but LSU is favored at home. The Tigers have the crowd, the atmosphere, and a chance to make a statement that could completely change their postseason outlook.
We're not convinced that makes LSU the better team.
Alabama has enough talent on both sides of the ball to win in Baton Rouge. The Crimson Tide are coming off a bye, giving Kalen DeBoer additional time to prepare for a matchup where offensive execution will be everything.
The key is avoiding the mistakes that turn Death Valley into a nightmare.
LSU thrives when opponents lose composure. False starts, turnovers, stalled drives, and suddenly a manageable game becomes a two-score deficit with 100,000 people losing their minds.
Alabama cannot let that happen.
Defensively, the Tigers could also be without linebacker Whit Weeks, who is working his way back from a fractured leg. That matters against an Alabama offense that will look to establish rhythm and sustain drives.
We think the Crimson Tide can move the football.
We also think LSU will have success of its own.
Which brings us to one of our official Week 10 Board selections.
THE BANTRYM BOARD: ALABAMA–LSU OVER 52.5
We're expecting both offenses to have their moments.
Alabama has the weapons to generate explosive plays, while LSU should be able to capitalize on home-field advantage and the pressure that comes with this matchup.
Neither team needs to score 40 for this total to get there.
A competitive game in the high 20s or low 30s is enough.
Our biggest concern is that both defenses are talented enough to turn this into a field-position battle. But we see more offensive opportunities than the total suggests.
BANTRYM PREDICTION: ALABAMA WINS. OVER 52.5 HITS.
No. 9 BYU at No. 3 Utah: The Holy War Has Never Felt Bigger
Saturday, Noon ET | Salt Lake City, Utah
Forget the records for a second.
This is BYU versus Utah.
These teams don't need playoff implications to hate each other.
But this year? We've got both.
Utah enters undefeated at 8-0, ranked third in the country and firmly in the driver's seat of the Big 12 race.
BYU is 7-1, ranked ninth, and knows that a victory in Salt Lake City would dramatically strengthen its playoff résumé.
The stakes are enormous.
The matchup also favors Utah in some important areas.
The Utes have been one of the country's most balanced teams, averaging nearly 39 points per game while allowing fewer than 16. Quarterback Devon Dampier gives them a legitimate dual-threat presence, and the rushing attack has consistently created problems for opposing defenses.
BYU's biggest concern is its own running game.
Running back LJ Martin is officially listed as doubtful, and even if he plays, he won't be at full strength. BYU's ground game has dropped off in every game without him. If that continues, Utah's defense can make this an extremely long afternoon for BYU quarterback Bear Bachmeier.
Utah has offensive line injuries of its own, so this isn't a completely one-sided matchup.
But we trust the Utes' ability to control the game more than we trust BYU to consistently move the football.
And there's another factor.
Rice-Eccles Stadium is going to be absolutely ridiculous.
⭐ THE BANTRYM BOARD BEST BET: UTAH MONEYLINE
We're not asking Utah to win by two touchdowns.
We're asking the undefeated, third-ranked team in the country to protect its home field against its biggest rival.
Utah's defensive consistency, rushing attack, and home-field advantage give us enough confidence to make the Utes our official Week 10 Best Bet.
BYU will make this uncomfortable. It's the Holy War. That's practically guaranteed.
But when the fourth quarter arrives, we trust Utah to make the plays that matter.
BANTRYM PREDICTION: UTAH WINS THE HOLY WAR.
No. 6 Kentucky at No. 13 Tennessee: We're Taking the Volunteers
Saturday, 6:15 PM ET | Knoxville, Tennessee
Kentucky being ranked sixth in November wasn't on many preseason bingo cards.
But here we are.
The Wildcats have been one of the season's biggest surprises under Will Stein, and at 7-1, they're firmly in the playoff conversation.
Now comes a trip to Knoxville.
And we think Tennessee is going to ruin the party.
The Volunteers are 6-2 and have already shown they can compete with high-level opponents. They're also playing at Neyland Stadium, where the environment alone can change the complexion of a game.
Tennessee's defense is the biggest reason we're leaning toward the home team.
The Volunteers have the personnel to disrupt Kentucky's offensive rhythm, create difficult third downs, and force the Wildcats to prove they can win a physical SEC game on the road.
Kentucky deserves credit for its season.
But there's a difference between being a great story and surviving every test on the schedule.
Tennessee has the talent, the home-field advantage, and the defensive matchup to hand Kentucky its second loss.
BANTRYM PREDICTION: TENNESSEE BEATS KENTUCKY.
No. 19 Iowa at Northwestern: Stop Sleeping on the Hawkeyes
Saturday, 7:30 PM ET | Evanston, Illinois
We're going to say something that might make a few Big Ten fans uncomfortable.
Iowa is playing some really good football.
Yes. Iowa.
The Hawkeyes are 6-2, ranked 19th in the initial playoff rankings, and coming off a 30-0 demolition of Wisconsin.
Not a typo.
Thirty to nothing.
And it wasn't some fluky performance where Iowa scored three defensive touchdowns and punted 11 times.
Quarterback Hank Brown completed 20 of 24 passes for 222 yards and two touchdowns.
Iowa's offense actually looked like an offense.
What a concept.
But the real story remains the defense.
The Hawkeyes are allowing just 12.5 points per game, ranking among the nation's best in scoring defense. They're also surrendering only 79 rushing yards per contest.
Northwestern presents a legitimate challenge.
The Wildcats are 6-2, and quarterback Aidan Chiles has been excellent, combining efficient passing with the ability to create plays on the ground.
Northwestern is also undefeated at home.
So no, this isn't a free win.
But Iowa's defensive front is built to limit the running game, and the Hawkeyes have the discipline to make Northwestern earn every yard.
The biggest question is whether Brown can build on last week's performance.
We're betting that he can.
Iowa doesn't need to score 40. It needs to control the line of scrimmage, avoid turnovers, and let its defense dictate the game.
That's exactly the kind of football this program wants to play.
And right now, it's working.
BANTRYM PREDICTION: IOWA BEATS NORTHWESTERN.
THE REST OF THE BANTRYM BOARD
We've already covered Alabama–LSU and Utah–BYU, but three more games made our official Week 10 card.
Here's why.
No. 7 Texas at No. 18 Missouri: The Longhorns Have More to Lose
THE BANTRYM BOARD: TEXAS -2.5
Texas enters Saturday with two losses and very little room for another mistake.
The Longhorns have recovered from consecutive defeats against Oklahoma and Florida with wins over Ole Miss and Mississippi State. They're playing better football, and their offense has started to look more like the unit people expected entering the season.
Missouri isn't going to make this easy.
The Tigers are undefeated at home and coming off a convincing victory over Arkansas. Their rushing attack, led by Jamal Roberts, is capable of controlling possession and keeping opposing offenses on the sideline.
Texas also has injury concerns.
Left tackle Trevor Goosby is out, and receivers Ryan Wingo and Cam Coleman have been listed as questionable.
Those aren't minor absences.
But the Longhorns still have enough talent to win this matchup.
The key is forcing Missouri into obvious passing situations and preventing the Tigers from turning this into a slow, physical game.
Texas doesn't need to dominate.
It needs to win the line of scrimmage often enough, protect the football, and finish drives.
We think it does.
BANTRYM PREDICTION: TEXAS WINS AND COVERS -2.5.
No. 8 UCLA at Minnesota: The Bruins Keep Rolling
THE BANTRYM BOARD: UCLA -5.5
UCLA might be the most underappreciated undefeated team in college football.
The Bruins are 8-0, sitting atop the Big Ten standings, and doing it despite losing starting quarterback Nico Iamaleava for the season.
That should have derailed their year.
Instead, Ty Dieffenbach has helped keep the offense moving, and Bob Chesney's team continues to find ways to win.
Minnesota is better than its record might suggest.
The Golden Gophers just pushed Indiana to overtime, proving they can compete with elite Big Ten opponents.
That's what makes this game dangerous.
Minnesota has enough defensive talent to keep the score close, and playing at home gives the Gophers a legitimate opportunity to pull an upset.
But UCLA has been the more consistent team.
The Bruins have found a formula that works: protect the football, play disciplined defense, and capitalize when opponents make mistakes.
We expect Minnesota to make UCLA work for it.
We don't expect the Gophers to finish the job.
BANTRYM PREDICTION: UCLA WINS AND COVERS -5.5.
Vanderbilt at Mississippi State: Give Us Points
THE BANTRYM BOARD: OVER 48.5
Not every game on this week's Board has national championship implications.
Sometimes, we just see a total we like.
Vanderbilt travels to Starkville to face a Mississippi State team looking to recover from a rough loss to Texas.
Neither program has been particularly consistent, but that's part of what makes this matchup interesting.
Mississippi State has the offensive advantage on paper and should be able to generate scoring opportunities against Vanderbilt.
The Commodores, meanwhile, don't need to control the game to help this total.
They need to sustain enough drives to contribute points and force Mississippi State to keep attacking.
Our concern is that either offense could stall for extended stretches.
But with the number sitting at 48.5, we're looking for a game where both teams find the end zone multiple times.
Something in the neighborhood of 31-21 gets us there.
BANTRYM PREDICTION: VANDERBILT–MISSISSIPPI STATE OVER 48.5.
No. 2 Georgia at No. 10 Ole Miss: Don't Forget About the Bulldogs
Saturday, 7:30 PM ET | Oxford, Mississippi
With Miami–Notre Dame getting most of the national attention, this matchup has somehow become an afterthought.
That's ridiculous.
Georgia is ranked second in the country.
Ole Miss is tenth.
And the Rebels get the Bulldogs at home with a chance to deliver one of the biggest wins of their season.
Georgia's biggest advantage is its defense.
The Bulldogs have the personnel to disrupt an Ole Miss offense that prefers to play aggressively and create explosive opportunities.
The Rebels will have their moments, especially in front of their home crowd.
But Georgia is built to survive exactly this kind of game.
We trust the Bulldogs to control the line of scrimmage, avoid unnecessary mistakes, and make Ole Miss work for every possession.
It might not be pretty.
But Georgia doesn't need pretty.
BANTRYM PREDICTION: GEORGIA WINS IN OXFORD.
THE PLAYOFF PICTURE AFTER SATURDAY
Let's put it all together.
If our predictions hold, Miami remains undefeated, Utah survives the Holy War, Georgia handles Ole Miss, and Alabama adds another major win to its résumé.
Ohio State gets back on track, Tennessee knocks Kentucky down a peg, and Iowa keeps quietly building one of the more interesting résumés in the Big Ten.
Notre Dame would be staring at a second loss with limited opportunities remaining to impress the committee.
BYU would have two losses and a much more difficult path to a favorable playoff seed.
Kentucky would go from one of the nation's biggest surprises to a team suddenly needing to prove it belongs.
And Oregon?
A fourth loss could make the Ducks' playoff path extremely difficult.
That's the beauty of November college football.
The rankings come out on Tuesday.
Everyone argues about them for four days.
Then Saturday arrives and makes half the arguments irrelevant.
FINAL WORD
We've spent two months trying to figure out who's actually good.
Now we find out who's built for November.
Miami has to prove it can win without Malachi Toney. Alabama has to handle Death Valley. Ohio State has to respond to adversity. Utah has to survive its biggest rival. And several playoff hopefuls are about to discover how quickly one bad Saturday can change everything.
Our calls are in.
Miami. Ohio State. Alabama. Utah. Tennessee. Iowa. Georgia.
And five official selections on the Bantrym Board.
Somebody's season is about to change.
Probably several somebodies.
NOBODY ASKED. WE'RE SAYING IT ANYWAY.
The Bantrym Board enters Week 10 at 22-20-1 overall and 3-6 on Best Bets. Betting lines reflect selections at the time of posting.